← All guides

Claim short settled? Why the payout came in below the bill — and how to recover the difference

When the insurer pays, but pays less than the hospital bill, that is a short settlement — and you do not have to simply accept the gap. An underpaid claim can be challenged through exactly the same free escalation path as a rejected one. The first step is understanding what was cut and why.

Step 1 — get the deduction worked out line by line

Ask the insurer, in writing, for the settlement statement with every deduction itemized: which bill line was cut, by how much, and under which policy clause. Everything below — and any grievance you file — is built on that sheet.

The usual cuts, and which are challengeable

The biggest single cause is the room-rent limit: take a costlier room than the policy's cap and the insurer can scale down linked charges proportionately. But IRDAI's proportionate-deduction norms limit how far that goes — the cut cannot be applied to ICU charges, or to implants, pharmacy, diagnostics and medical devices, and if the hospital doesn't price rooms differently by category there is no basis for a proportionate deduction at all. Our room-rent guide walks through the arithmetic.

Cuts that the policy wording itself sets — a room-rent cap, disease sub-limits, a co-pay percentage — are legitimate if applied as written. The question a short-settled claim turns on is whether they were applied correctly, and the line-by-line sheet is what shows that.

Run your own numbers

ClaimSarathi's claim check can include a shortfall calculator: give it the hospital bill (and the room rent you took), and it estimates what the policy should pay and what stays out of pocket — each cut shown next to the clause in your own policy that drives it. Compare that estimate with what the insurer actually paid to size the gap for your grievance. It appears when the scan verifies your sum insured and the relevant limit clauses.

The recovery path (free at every step)

Raise a written grievance with the insurer's Grievance Redressal Officer citing the specific deductions you dispute — the insurer must respond in about 15 days. Unresolved or unsatisfactory? Escalate on IRDAI's Bima Bharosa portal (bimabharosa.irdai.gov.in). Still short-changed? The Insurance Ombudsman is free and binding on the insurer, with an award cap of about ₹50 lakh — file within 1 year.

General guidance — verify against your policy wording and the cited IRDAI sources. Sources: IRDAI 'Norms on Proportionate Deductions' (2020) / Master Circular on Health Insurance Business, 29 May 2024; Insurance Ombudsman Rules 2017 (amended Nov 2023).

Frequently asked

Can I challenge a claim that was paid, just paid less?

Yes. A short settlement follows the same free path as a rejection: written grievance to the insurer's GRO, then IRDAI's Bima Bharosa portal, then the Insurance Ombudsman (free, binding on the insurer, cap about ₹50 lakh, file within 1 year).

Which deductions are NOT allowed?

Under IRDAI's proportionate-deduction norms, a room-rent-based proportionate cut cannot be applied to ICU charges, or to implants, pharmacy, diagnostics and medical devices — and there is no basis for one at all if the hospital doesn't price rooms differently by category.

What do I need before filing a grievance?

The insurer's settlement statement with each deduction itemized — which line was cut, by how much, under which policy clause. Ask for it in writing; your grievance disputes specific lines, not the total.

IRDAI 'Norms on Proportionate Deductions' (IRDAI/HLT/REG/CIR/151/06/2020, eff. 1 Oct 2020), carried into the IRDAI Master Circular on Health Insurance Business, 29 May 2024; Insurance Ombudsman Rules 2017 (award cap raised to ₹50 lakh, Nov 2023 amendment) · As of 2026-07-04